The NFL Week 5 slate is jam-packed with thrilling matchups that are sure to have you on the edge of your seat all day Sunday. With some of the game’s top stars ready to suit up for action, take the excitement level to new heights by placing a wager on the best NFL player prop bets.
Below, we’ve scoured the latest NFL odds and highlighted our expert predictions for Week 5 so you can win big on all the upcoming action. Not only have we highlighted each pick, but we’ve also provided in-depth analysis so you can get a thorough understanding of why these are the best bets for this Sunday.
Don’t wait, head to your favourite NFL betting site, load up your bet slip ahead of kickoff in the early window, and get ready to see your bankroll skyrocket thanks to our best NFL Week 5 player prop bets and expert predictions.
- Bhayshul Tuten Over 63.5 Rushing Yards
- Malik Willis Over 182.5 Passing Yards
- Malik Nabers Over 4.5 Receptions
Bhayshul Tuten Over 63.5 Rushing Yards
In the midst of a breakout second-year season in the NFL, expect another big performance out of Jacksonville Jaguars running back Bhayshul Tuten as he racks up Over 63.5 rushing yards against the Philadelphia Eagles.
Having surpassed Over 63.5 rushing yards in all four games played so far in the 2026 season, Tuten has quickly cemented his spot as the top rusher for the Jaguars, providing consistent production on a weekly basis. Set to take on an Eagles squad that ranks in the bottom 10 of the NFL in rushing yards allowed per game at 122 per contest, Tuten has an opportune Week 5 matchup ahead of him.
With the Jags looking to extend their winning streak to three games, bank on Tuten to be a major contributor in their offence, slicing and dicing through the line of scrimmage and picking up chunk yardage throughout the contest as he finishes with Over 63.5 rushing yards against the Eagles.
Malik Willis Over 182.5 Passing Yards
It certainly hasn’t been sunshine and rainbows for the Miami Dolphins this season, as they’ve gotten off to a 0-4 start to the season, with bad injury luck and lacklustre play plaguing them early on this year. While there may not be brighter days on the horizon, you can still snag a win on your NFL bet slip as you back Dolphins quarterback Malik Willis to pass for Over 182.5 yards.
Placed in an unfortunate situation, Willis is at the helm of one of the worst rosters in the NFL. Despite the lack of talent around him, Willis has produced well in the early stages of the 2026 season. Through his first four games of the 2026 season, Willis has tallied Over 182.5 passing yards three times, with the lone exception coming last week against a stellar Vikings defence.
Set for a much more favourable defensive matchup as he faces off against the Cincinnati Bengals who rank 26th in the NFL this season in passing yards allowed per game, look for Willis to get back on track as he racks up Over 182.5 passing yards, providing his team a glimmer of hope in what’s sure to be a high-scoring showdown.
Malik Nabers Over 4.5 Receptions
Rounding out our best Week 5 player prop bets, look for New York Giants star wide receiver Malik Nabers to torch the Washington Commanders defence in a pivotal NFC East clash, recording Over 4.5 receptions on the day.
Since being drafted in 2024, Nabers has been borderline unstoppable in open space. With 145 receptions over 23 games, Nabers is primed to enter historic territory, as he already ranks within the top five in receptions in the first 25 games of an NFL career. Set to take on a Commanders defence that’s allowed the seventh-most completions per game across the NFL, fourth-most when specifically looking at completions made to wide receivers.
As the Giants passing attack is still primarily run through Nabers, expect another big performance from the 23-year-old phenom, grabbing Over 4.5 receptions for the fourth time this season, cashing for a plus money player prop in the process.
