The Toronto Blue Jays hit the road to face the Milwaukee Brewers in a matchup that could swing momentum for both clubs early in the season, and the latest Blue Jays vs. Brewers odds point to a tight, low‑scoring game with real value on the board.
Toronto arrives with injuries still piling up and a struggling offence, while Milwaukee looks to snap a five‑game slide behind a live young arm in Jacob Misiorowski. With Kevin Gausman set to square off against Misiorowski under the dome in Milwaukee, our Blue Jays vs. Brewers odds breakdown includes best bets, predictions, and key player props for Tuesday’s matchup.
Blue Jays vs. Brewers best bet
F5 under 3.5 runs: +100 (Pinnacle)
F5 under 3.5 runs
We’ve got a premium starting pitching matchup on Tuesday between Gausman and Misiorowski under controlled weather conditions in an indoor venue. Both teams are dealing with injuries to some key offensive players (see section below on injuries), further suggesting we should see a low-scoring affair between these teams, especially early in the game when these two elite right-handers are battling it out.
In 79 combined at-bats against Gausman, Milwaukee’s roster owns a paltry .177/.226/.278 slash line with a .505 team OPS. On the other side, not a single Blue Jays player has faced Misiorowski before, giving him a major element of surprise. It’ll likely be a rough couple of times through the order before the Blue Jays can hone in on the Brewers righty.
You can find the best Blue Jays vs. Brewers F5 under odds at Pinnacle (+100) on Tuesday, but be sure to check out the best MLB betting sites to ensure you’re getting the best odds.
Blue Jays vs. Brewers odds
| Blue Jays moneyline odds | +110 |
| Brewers moneyline odds | -130 |
| Run line odds | Brewers -1.5 (+175), Blue Jays +1.5 (-210) |
| Game total | Over 7 runs (-120), Under 7 runs (+100) |
| Date/time | April 14, 7:40 p.m. ET |
Betting the Blue Jays (6-9 SU, 4-11 ATS, 8-7 o/u)
The Blue Jays are treading water at this point after dealing with a myriad of injuries in April. They dropped two of three games to the Minnesota Twins over the weekend, their fourth straight series loss after opening the season with a three-game sweep over the Athletics.
Unfortunately, it’ll likely be another week or two before Toronto starts getting some healthy bodies back into the lineup, so it’s pivotal for the team to scratch its way to a few victories to close out the month in order to remain competitive in the loaded AL East.
The Blue Jays have scored just 57 runs through 15 games, which ranks 25th in the majors.
Betting the Brewers (8-7 SU, 9-6 ATS, 9-6 o/u)
After a strong 8-2 start to the season, the Brewers now find themselves mired in a five-game losing streak heading into this series. Their bats have gone completely silent, scoring a total of just 12 runs during the five-game skid. They’ve been held to two runs or less in three of those five contests.
However, they still rank fifth in the majors in runs (80) and fifth in team OPS (.726), which is a true testament to just how well the team played in its first 10 games out of the gate.
Milwaukee has received mediocre pitching to this point in the season, ranking in the middle of the pack in most team statistical categories, but it’ll be sending its new staff ace to the hill in Tuesday’s series opener to battle Toronto.
Probable starting pitchers
Toronto: RHP Kevin Gausman (0-1, 2.08 ERA, 0.63 WHIP, 13.50 K/9)
Gausman has been superb for the Blue Jays in his three regular-season starts, most notably holding the loaded Los Angeles Dodgers to three earned runs on six hits over 5 1/3 innings of work the last time he took the ball.
He was nearly untouchable in his first two outings, holding the Colorado Rockies and Athletics to a combined one earned run and three hits over 12 innings.
Gausman’s signature pitch, his splitter, has been electric, holding the opposition to a .147 batting average and .167 xBA, while accounting for 14 of his 26 strikeouts this season.
Milwaukee: RHP Jacob Misiorowski (1-1, 3.31 ERA, 1.04 WHIP, 15.43 K/9)
Misiorowski is picking up right where he left off during his rookie campaign in 2025, showcasing a 99-mph fastball that is giving the opposition nightmares.
His ridiculous 15.43 K/9 mark to this point obviously isn’t sustainable throughout the entirety of a season, but it does suggest the 24-year-old right-hander is among the elite strikeout pitchers in the majors.
Misiorowski has allowed three earned runs or less across each of his first three starts while ranking in the 96th percentile in fastball velocity.
No player on Toronto’s roster has a previous at-bat against Misiorowski, which means he’ll have the element of surprise working in his favour against the Blue Jays on Tuesday.
Notable injuries
The following notable players on the injured list for the Blue Jays:
- F Anthony Santander (shoulder)
- P Cody Ponce (knee)
- C Alejandro Kirk (thumb)
- P Trey Yesavage (shoulder)
- P Jose Berrios (elbow)
- P Shane Bieber (elbow)
- P Yimi Garcia (elbow)
- P Bowden Francis (elbow)
- OF Addison Barger (ankle)
- OF George Springer (toe)
C Tyler Heineman is also day-to-day with back spasms.
The following notable players are on the injured list for the Brewers:
- OF Jackson Chourio (hand)
- 1B Andrew Vaughn (hand)
- P Quinn Priester (wrist)
OF Christian Yelich is day-to-day with a hamstring injury, and P Kyle Harrison is also DTD with knee and wrist issues.
Weather
There’s a risk of strong thunderstorms Tuesday evening in Milwaukee, so the retractable dome at the ballpark will very likely be closed.
Blue Jays vs. Brewers betting trends
- The Blue Jays have hit the F5 team total under in 12 of their 15 games.
- Toronto is 0-3 SU on the road this season.
- Milwaukee is 8-4 against American League foes this season.
- The Brewers have won four of the past six meetings between these teams.
Blue Jays vs. Brewers player prop trends
- Misiorowski has recorded seven strikeouts or more in four straight starts dating back to last season, averaging 9.25 per start during that span. He’s around -130 to beat that number on Tuesday night against a stingy Blue Jays team that only strikes out seven times per game.
- Brewers catcher William Contreras is taking an eight-game hitting streak into action Tuesday. He’s -200 to extend that streak.
- Blue Jays outfielder Jesus Sanchez has hit safely in five straight games and is -125 to get a hit.
- Brewers second baseman Brice Turang has drawn at least one walk in five straight games and is +150 to do it again Tuesday.
- Blue Jays outfielder Daulton Varsho has driven in at least one run in four straight games and is +210 to extend that streak.