The Montreal Canadiens shattered expectations in Game 1 and now head into a tight second matchup looking for a 2–0 series lead, making this Canadiens vs. Lightning prediction one of the most intriguing playoff games of the week. With Tampa Bay heavy favourites at home, the Canadiens vs. Lightning odds lean toward the Lightning, but the eye test and underlying numbers suggest another tightly contested, low‑scoring battle could keep Montreal in play late.
Though Game 1 was quite evenly contested, the Canadiens remain significant underdogs in Game 2, currently priced at +160 at the time of writing. Game 2 of this series between two defensive juggernauts seems to be a good time to ride with that trend, as we will outline below, as well as the relevant betting notes for both teams.
Canadiens vs. Lightning best bet
Regulation Tie +320 (Play to +310)
Game to require overtime
It’s extremely tough to take a 2-0 series lead on the road versus a seasoned team like the Tampa Bay Lightning. But the expectation that Tampa Bay will elevate its game seems to be baked heavily into the betting prices on this game, and there certainly seems to be a “must-win” tax incorporated into the numbers.
The Lightning generated 0.78 expected goals at even strength in Game 1, while the Canadiens generated 1.30. I’d be in complete agreement that the eye test suggested the game was quite evenly played at even strength, but at worst, it was a really solid showing at even strength from a Canadiens side that was expected to be heavily outperformed in that regard.
We were high on the Canadiens entering the season relative to betting odds, and were also high on them entering this series. While it does seem likely that, at worst, the Lightning will make this game highly competitive, Montreal’s ability to hang tough with the Lightning still seems to be overvalued entering Game 2.
So while targeting the Canadiens to take a shocking 2-0 series lead would be my preferred angle in terms of a side, taking a really long price of +320 for this game to reach overtime looks quite appealing.
The Canadiens should be capable of authoring a similar performance, and at worst, keeping the scoreline close and giving themselves a legitimate chance to win. It seems unlikely they will ever be able to win this game by a comfortable margin, but a closely contested, back-and-forth game seems to be a logical game script, and would therefore keep this long shot within reach.
Canadiens vs. Lightning Odds
| Canadiens moneyline odds | +160 |
| Lightning moneyline odds | -190 |
| Puck Line odds | Canadiens +1.5 (-160), Lightning -1.5 (+135) |
| Series odds | Canadiens (-105), Lightning (-115) |
| Game total | Over 6 goals (-105), Under 6 (-115) |
Odds courtesy of bet365.
Betting Montreal Canadiens
One of the reasons that we believed the Canadiens could hang tough in this series was belief that the Canadiens’ top stars could offer a comparable level to the Lightning’s elite talents. That was the case in Game 1, as Nick Suzuki, Cole Caufield, Juraj Slafkovsky, and Lane Hutson combined for eight points.
Though all of those points came on the power play, Montreal’s top stars did a solid job at even strength in tough minutes versus the Lightning’s stacked top-six.
Hutson, in particular, had a strong defensive showing, given that his defensive upside is never thought to be the greatest strength of his game. While Hutson is a smaller defender and is therefore not thought of as the type to succeed in the postseason, his ability to beat the Lightning forecheck with both his legs and strong breakout passing was noteworthy.
The ability to make plays with less space in the playoffs is an underrated asset, obvious as though it may be. While none of Suzuki, Caufield or Suzuki are imposing physically, they did not look overwhelmed by the lack of space in Saturday’s matchup, which is really encouraging for the team.
Jakub Dobes stopped 16 of 19 shots faced, but though his save percentage was not excellent, he still was the sharper of the two goaltenders, which was another narrative that seemed more possible than was generally expected entering the series.
Predicting which goaltenders will succeed each postseason is more volatile than is generally credited, and Dobes tremendous finish to the campaign suggested it wasn’t entirely unrealistic that he could play equal to Vasilevskiy, who has somewhat quietly had very little playoff success over the last several seasons. ‘
Betting Tampa Bay Lightning
The Lightning obviously deserve to be favoured to win this game, but is expecting them to win the game 66% of the time accurate? That’s the question here, which is why I’d like to frame these thoughts from that perspective.
The Lightning will be desperate to respond in Game 2, as they look to avoid heading back to Montreal in an 0-2 hole. From a betting perspective, we saw a highly similar narrative take place last season when the Lightning took on the Florida Panthers, as the Lightning seemingly seemed to be overvalued based on the ‘do-or-die’ nature of the game.
While the Canadiens still have a ton to prove to be considered anywhere near what the Panthers were last season, if the Lightning fail to offer an elevated performance in this game, it will really start to feel as though the perception that this current core is made to thrive in the postseason is based too heavily upon what they accomplished several years ago.
Vasilevskiy now holds a save percentage of .878 and a GAA of 3.40 in 17 games played dating back to the start of the 2022-23 postseason. We’ve discussed a lot how predicting which goaltenders will thrive each postseason can be difficult, and Vasilveskiy is a good case in point.
Victor Hedman is expected to remain sidelined for the majority of Round 1. Hedman had a significant dropoff in form this season, and the Lightning have the defensive depth to account for that loss. But the names playing in place of Hedman are less proven in the postseason, while the loss of Charle-Edouard D’Astous to injury is notable.
With all of those things said, the Lightning still hold a stacked lineup with no clear flaws and, by most predictive indicators, are a full-fledged Stanley Cup contender. But they definitely have some questions to answer in Game 2, and in recent years have not necessarily proven the ability to elevate their level of play this time of year.
You can follow all of Nick’s hockey bets on the Action Network App!